HASHTRACKER

Marketing reports 2 min read

How to compare social media accounts fairly

When you compare social media accounts, totals favour whoever posts most. Normalise by impressions per post and compare within formats instead of overall.

Cover drawn as the blocks of a report

Comparing social media accounts sounds simple until you notice one posts four times a day and the other twice a week.

Totals will always favour the first. The comparison has to correct for that or it says nothing.

Normalise before you compare

Absolute totals measure output, not performance. Three figures fix it. Impressions per post, engagement per post and engagement rate. All three are independent of how much each account published, which is the whole point.

Tell us which accounts to compare and we will set the measurement up identically for all of them.

Tell us which accounts to compare

Measure the same period and the same way

Same start and end date, same decision about reposts, same source for every account. This sounds obvious and it is the most common failure. One account measured over a month that contained its product launch against another measured over a quiet month produces a chart that is pure noise.

If one account had an unusual event in the period, say so in the report rather than quietly excluding it.

The figure that reorders everything

Impressions per post exposes audience quality in a way follower counts never do. An account with 300,000 followers averaging 4,000 impressions has an audience that stopped listening. One with 12,000 followers averaging 9,000 has a real one. On a follower chart the first looks twenty five times bigger.

Put both columns side by side in the report. The gap between them is usually the most discussed slide.

Compare formats, not just accounts

Split each account's posts by format and compare within the format. Account A may beat account B overall while losing badly on video. That is actionable in a way an overall ranking is not, because it tells you what to copy rather than who to envy.

Cadence and timing

Group each account's posts by hour and weekday, then put impressions next to the posting times. Plenty of accounts post most at the hour that performs worst for them. It is a cheap finding and it is usually true.

What makes the comparison defensible

Name the accounts, the period, the query and the normalisation. Say why those accounts and not others. A comparison with unexplained choices gets questioned in the first five minutes. We hand over the rows so every account can be audited separately. Tell us the set and we will build it.

Tell us the set

Choosing a subscription

Every subscription carries the same product. The only decision is how many tweets you need to analyse.

See the subscriptions